I’ve heard family stories about an ancestor who fought on both sides during the Civil War, but I didn’t really believe it. Two brothers fighting on opposite sides? Yeah, okay. But one man fighting for both sides over the course of the war? Seemed a little far-fetched.
Wars are always justified as necessary to stand-up for our principals or our rights, or to fight evil, or protect the mother land. But it seems to me that when it came to joining up during the Civil War to fight for one side or the other, the reasoning was black or white. You either believed in the Rebel cause or you believed in the Union and the destruction of slavery. So, it doesn’t seem probable that one person would enlist in both armies—by choice—between 1861 and 1865.
And, yet, I think that’s exactly what Benjamin Houdeshell did.
According to Benjamin’s death certificate, he was born 13 March 1842 in Maryland and died 20 March 1926 in Rush Township, Centre County, Pennsylvania. He was 84 years old. His full name was James Benjamin Houdeshell. His obituary read:
Recent Deaths: Houdeshell – Benjamin Houdeshell, Civil War Veteran, father of John Houdeshell, of Curtin, and well known resident of the Philipsburg community, passed away at the home of his daughter, Mrs. Thomas Passell, Saturday morning [20 March]. He had been in failing health for the past four years, death being due to infirmities of age. The funeral service was held Tuesday afternoon; internment in the Philipsburg Cemetery. Deceased, is a son of Adam and Mary Houdeshell, was born at Westmoreland, Virginia, on March 13, 1842, making his age 84 years and 7 days. He enlisted as a Private in Company I, Thirteenth Regiment of Maryland Infantry, February 24, 1865, and was mustered out at the close of the War. He was a woodsman and farmer, and for twenty years or longer has been residing in the Philipsburg region. The wife of the deceased was Pheobe Mayes, who died five years ago last August. Twelve children were born to the marriage. The surviving sons and daughters are: John, of Curtin; Mrs. Jacob Webb, of Windber; George, of Surveyor Run; Frank and Jacob, of Kato; Mrs. Thomas Passell, of North Philipsburg; Mrs. Daniel DeHaas, of Julian, and Mrs. Nora Blake and Mrs. Ernest Vinton, of Philipsburg.
The military pension index card for “Benjamin Houdeshell” lists his death date as 20 March 1926 and place of death as Phillipsburg, Pennsylvania. So, it matches my 3x great grandfather’s death certificate. It also states that he served as a private in the 13th Regiment, Company I of the Maryland Infantry, mustering in on 24 February 1865 and out on 29 May 1865.
Fortunately, additional records for Maryland Civil War Soldiers are online at Fold3.com. Benjamin’s record for Company I, 13th Regiment includes his volunteer enlistment. He enlisted at Frederick, Maryland on 24 February 1865, stating that he was 19 years old, born in Hardy County, Virginia, and a laborer. The record also states that he was 5′ 6″ tall and had grey eyes, light hair and a fair complexion.
Neither the description nor his age on this record matches other information I have regarding Benjamin. Born in 1842, he would have been 22 years old, nearly 23, in February 1865. And the one photo I have of him shows him with dark hair. However, based on the information in his obituary and pension index card, this is the record of enlistment for my great great great grandfather.
So, there’s his Union service. What about his Confederate service?
The enlistment record states that he was born in Hardy County, Virginia. Census records for 1860 show Benjamin Houdeshell, aged 18, living in the household of Adam Howyshell (his father per his obituary) in District No. 1, Hardy County.
The household included:
- Adam Howdyshell, aged 69, Farmer, born in Virginia
- Mary “, aged 64, born Virginia
- John Wm “, aged 28, born Virginia
- George W. “, aged 21, born Virginia
- Benjamin “, aged 18, born Virginia
On the next page are the households of:
- Adam Howdyshell Jr., age 40, Laborer, born in Virginia
- Mary “, age 42, born in Virginia
- Daniel “, age 13, born in Virginia
- Sarah C. ” , age 11, born in Virginia
- John W. “, age 8, born in Virginia
- William E. “, age 5, born in Virginia
- Daniel Howdyshell, age 37, Laborer, born in Virginia
- Jane “, age 24, born in Virginia
- Elizabeth “, age 7, born in Virginia
- Benjamin “, aged 5, born in Virginia
- Joseph “, aged 3, born in Virginia
- Virginia “, aged 1, born in Virginia
- Isaac Howdyshell, aged 23, Laborer, born in Virginia
- Dorothy “, aged 58, born in Virginia
Adam’s household in 1850 included:
- Adam Howdyshell, aged 63, Farmer, born Virginia
- Mary “, aged 49, born Virginia
- John W., aged 18, Laborer, born Virginia
- Isaac, aged 14, born Virginia
- Westfall, aged 10, born Virginia
- Benjamin, aged 7, born Virginia
A search of the Confederate Civil War Soldiers on Fold3.com turns up records for the 14th Regiment, Virginia Militia for Adam Howdyshell Jr., J. Benjamin Howdyshell and Westfall Howdyshell.
All three men enlisted on 17 September 1861 in Wardensville, Hardy County, Virginia. The names, approximate ages, and place of enlistment seems to indicate that these three men may very well have been the sons of Adam Howdyshell of Hardy County. They enlisted for the period of six months and it’s entirely possible that is all they served.
If, in fact, they are Adam’s sons (and it seems likely), then my great great grandfather, James Benjamin Houdeshell, served in both the Confederate and Union armies during the Civil War.
Why would he do that?
First, I have to think that he did not have any great convictions regarding slavery. Based on the 1860 census, the Houdeshells were not wealthy land-owners and, as far as I can tell, not slave-owners either. Adam’s real estate was worth $1,000 and he did not list any personal estate. I searched the slave schedules for Hardy County in 1860. It did not include the 1st district. Whether this was because there were no slave-owners there or it has been lost, I do not know. However, the county supposedly has a “rich African American history, with many free African Americans living there before the Civil War.”
Additionally, he may have been a member of the militia prior to the war, serving as a home guard. The militia was ordered into service with the Confederate Army on 10 September 1861 by the governor of Virginia. The 14th “played a roll in Jackson’s January 1862 Romney campaign after which the 14th was assigned to the ‘region of their homes’.” That may be how he came to serve in the Confederate forces, rather than a voluntary enlistment.
On 6 November 1864, Benjamin married Phoebe Mayes of Snow Shoe Township, Centre County, Pennsylvania. That’s nearly four months before he enlisted in the Maryland Infantry on 24 February 1865. It’s possible he enlisted because he needed the money to support his family. I don’t imagine that there were that many jobs available during the winter in the mountains of Centre County. The government bounty—for which the record indicates he was eligible—might have been tempting to a young man in his position.
I don’t know what happened to Benjamin between his enlistment in September 1861 in the Confederate Army and his marriage in November 1864 to a Pennsylvanian girl. So, it’s hard to say with any certainty why he enlisted twice—in two opposing armies. But I bet it’s an interesting story.
This post is part of an on-going blogging challenge entitled 52 Ancestors in 52 Weeks, created by Amy Crow of No Story Too Small. Participants must write about one ancestor every week. This is my second post for 52 Ancestors and is part of week three.
- Pennsylvania, Department of Health, death certificate no. 35022 (1926), James Benjamin Houdeshell; Bureau of Vital Statistics, New Castle. ↩
- 276. Cordes W. Chambers, The Mountaintop through Newspaper Accounts – 1926-1930 (Bellefonte, Pennsylvania: Grove Printing, 1995), Volume 4, page 12; citing The Centre Democrat, Centre County, Pennsylvania, 25 March 1926 (Thursday). ↩
- Fold3.com, “Civil War and Later Veterans Pension Index” (http://www.fold3.com/title_57/civil_war_and_later_veterans_pension_index/ : accessed 17 Aug 2013), index card for Benjamin Houdeshell; citing National Archives and Records Administration, micropublication T289, “Organization Index to Pension Files of Veterans Who Served Between 1861 and 1900,” records group 15; Phillipsburg adjoins Rush Township in Centre County. ↩
- Fold3.com, “Civil War Soldiers, Union, Maryland” (http://www.fold3.com/title_695/maryland/ : accessed 17 Aug 2013), service records for Benjamin Houdeshell; citing National Archives and Records Administration, micropublication M384, “Compiled Service Records of Volunteer Union Soldiers who Served in Organizations from the State of Maryland,” records group 94, film 0226. ↩
- 1860 United States Federal Census, Hardy County, Virginia, population schedules, post office: Wardensville, District No. 1, page 55 (written), dwelling 380, family 386, Adam Howdyshell household; digital image, Ancestry.com, “1860 United States Federal Census” (https://www.ancestry.com : accessed 8 Apr 2013); citing National Archives and Records Administration, micropublication M653, roll 1351. ↩
- 1860 United States Federal Census, Hardy County, Virginia, population schedules, post office: Bakers Run, District No. 1, page 56 (written), dwelling 386-388, family 392-394, Adam, Daniel and Isaac Howdyshell households; digital image, Ancestry.com, “1860 United States Federal Census” (https://www.ancestry.com : accessed 8 Apr 2013); citing National Archives and Records Administration, micropublication M653, roll 1351. ↩
- 1850 United States Federal Census, Hardy County, Virginia, population schedule, 23rd District, page 39 (stamped), dwelling 509, family 516, Adam Howdyshell household; digital image, Ancestry.com, “1850 United States Federal Census” (https://www.ancestry.com : accessed 18 Aug 2013); citing National Archives and Records Administration, micropublication M432, roll 950. ↩
- Wikipedia, “Hardy County, West Virginia” (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hardy_County,_West_Virginia : accessed 11 Jan 2014). ↩
- Mark See, “14th VA Militia c. 1861 & Hardy County Sees in Southern Service,” SEE, discussion list, 3 May 2002 (http://archiver.rootsweb.ancestry.com/th/read/SEE/2002-05/1020450460 : accessed 11 Jan 2014). ↩
- I have no idea how they met—this man from West Virginia and girl from central Pennsylvania. Their first child, John W. Houdeshell, was born 12 July 1865 and they were married 46 years in 1910 according the 1910 census. I don’t have a citation for the exact date, but it was likely included in family tree I received from a Hoover relative. ↩
Cite This Page:
Kris Hocker, “52 Ancestors: James Benjamin Houdeshell (1842—1926),” /genealogy the genealogy & family research site of Kris Hocker, modified 15 Feb 2014 (http://www.krishocker.com/52-ancestors-james-benjamin-houdeshell-1842-1926/ : accessed 27 Nov 2014).
Content copyright © Kris Hocker. Please do not copy without prior permission, attribution, and link back to this page.